Bhuvan Shome (1969): Movie Review


By Murtaza Ali Khan (@apotofvestiges)

Featured in IMDb Critic Reviews
Bhuvan Shome, Movie Poster
Bhuvan Shome (1969) By Mrinal Sen



Bhuvan Shome is a 1969 Hindi classic film written and directed by the legendary Indian filmmaker Mrinal Sen and starring the renowned Bengali actor Utpal Dutt and Marathi actress Suhasini Mulay (making her film debut) in the pivotal roles. Bhuvan Shome also marked the debut of the celebrated Indian actor Amitabh Bachchan who narrates the film in a playfully sardonic voice. Sen’s screenplay is based on a Bengali story by Banaphool aka Balai Chand Mukhopadhya. Recipient of three National Awards—Best Feature Film, Best Director, Best Actor—Bhuvan Shome not only ended Mrinal Sen’s unsuccessful streak as a director but also played a pivotal role in establishing him as a filmmaker of international repute. One of the first few films to get funded by the National Film Development Corporation (NFDC), which was back then known as the Film Finance Corporation (FFC), Bhuvan Shome is also said to have pioneered the Indian New Wave.
Utpal Dutt in and as Bhuvan Shome
Utpal Dutt in and as Bhuvan Shome

The film revolves around a ruthless Bengali bureaucrat, working in the Indian Railways, named Bhuvan Shome who is greatly feared by his subordinates. A middle-aged widower, Bhuvan Shome has spent his life trying to be righteous and has zero tolerance for the corrupt or the incompetent. As informed by the narrator, once he even went to the extent of firing his own son. He is highly respected by everyone around him but being a martinet he is forced to live in abject solitude. One day, bored by his monotonous office routine, he decides to go on a bird hunting trip to Saurashtra—a flourishing region located on the Arabian Sea coast of the Indian state of Gujarat. Doomed to live in solitude, Bhuvan Shome, trapped in an alien land, quickly realizes that he has inadvertently pushed himself a bit too far out of his comfort zone. The rest of the movie is more like a journey of self-realization for Bhuvan Shome who gradually learns to appreciate the importance of human company.
Suhasini Mulay as Gauri in Mrinal Sen's Bhuvan Shome
Suhasini Mulay as Gauri in Mrinal Sen's Bhuvan Shome

Perhaps, the most striking thing about Bhuvan Shome is that it is minimalistic without being devoid of style. The plot is bereft of any structure and mostly conveys a randomness of thought on the part of the maker. Sen adopts a documentary style to devise the movie’s narrative. For introducing the titular character of Bhuvan Shome, a hardcore Bengali who for the most of his life has lived outside of Bengal, Sen uses a montage including pictures of Vivekanda, Rabindranath Tagore, Satyajit Ray, Ravi Shankar, and public agitation of the communists on the streets of Calcutta (now Kolkata), perhaps in a bid to accentuate upon the peculiarities of Bengal/Bengalis. Another unique aspect of Bhuvan Shome is Sen’s use of animation at different points in the narrative. Apparently, it didn’t go well with Sen’s more accomplished fellow Bengali filmmaker Satyajit Ray who censurably summed up Bhuvan Shome as “Big Bad Bureaucrat Reformed by Rustic Belle”. Although, Satyajit Ray may not have approved Bhuvan Shome at the time, the film’s influence on him is quite evident in Shatranj Ke Khilari (1977), which not only uses animations but also employs Amitabh Bachchan’s playfully sardonic voiceover narration.
Mrinal Sen's use of animation in Bhuvan Shome
Mrinal Sen's use of animation in Bhuvan Shome
There are several ways to approach Bhuvan Shome. At its most elementary level, it can be described as a film about a man’s bird hunting adventure on the shores of Saurashtra. The theme of hunting is often associated with the elite, upper class people trying to overcome their boredom. The bird hunting expedition in Bhuvan Shome harks to Jean Renoir's The Rules of the Game (1939). At another level, the film can be seen as a powerful character study of a strict bureaucrat who finds it difficult to survive the moment he steps outside the comforts of his cocooned existence. The film can also be looked upon as a treatise on human solitude and longing for companionship. Yet another way to approach the film is a social commentary on the great rural-urban divide in India. While a powerful bureaucrat like Bhuvan Shome living in the city is cruel to everyone around him, the people in the village are friendly and helpful even to the strangers. Bhuvan Shome is also a film about human camaraderie and trust. How a beautiful village girl named Gauri leaves everything aside to help a total stranger whom she sees as her guest. How Bhuvan Shome blindly trusts the young girl during his bird hunting expedition. One is reminded of Akira Kurosawa’s Oscar-winning masterpiece Dersu Uzala (1975). Some have even commented on the undercurrent of eroticism that runs through the movie. While it is quite obvious that Bhuvan Shome grows fond of the young village girl, there are a few scenes in the movie that obliquely suggest the possibility of sexual attraction.  
Gauri assists Bhuvan Shome during a bird hunting expedition
Gauri assists Bhuvan Shome during a bird hunting expedition
Mrinal Sen’s imaginative direction is brilliantly complemented by K. K. Mahajan’s breathtaking black & white cinematography which gives the movie its soul. Mahajan brilliantly captures the vast expanses of Gujarat’s desert land, even reminding one of the majestic desert scenes from David Lean’s Lawrence of Arabia (1962). The extreme close-ups reveal a lot about the characters even before we get to hear them talk. The overhead shots of moving railway tracks, horse/bullock carts are used to accentuate the toil associated with travel. The editing techniques employed in the film are quite clever. In addition to a couple of impressive montage sequences, the movie uses a lot of jump cuts and freeze-frames. There is a beautiful sequence in Bhuvan Shome which deserves a special mention wherein Gauri pretends to be on a swing and the camera strategically zooms in and out on her, imitating the swing action. Vijay Raghav Rao’s musical pieces immensely add to the experience.
Bhuvan Shome bids adiu to Gauri
Bhuvan Shome bids adiu to Gauri
Overall, Bhuvan Shome is a groundbreaking work of cinema that set the ball rolling for the Indian New Wave. The film is a testament to Mrinal Sen’s iconoclastic genius as filmmaker. Here is a piece of cinema that’s free from the conventions of plot and structure. Unburdened by the onus to provide any definitive endings/solutions to problems, this brand of cinema endeavors to encourage the viewers to actively participate in finding the answers to the questions posed by the filmmaker. Another strong point of Bhuvan Shome is the acting performances of Utpal Dutt and Suhasini Mulay. Anyone who aspires to become an actor ought to study Dutt’s performance in the movie very closely. A part as complex as Bhuvan Shome requires an actor to blend ruthlessness, vulnerability, and tenderness in equal parts, and, Dutt, of course, is up to the task. His eyes, facial expressions and body gestures together communicate a lot more than his verbal delivery. A lesser actor would have made the character of Bhuvan Shome look like some cartoon, but, Dutt, to his credit, breathes life into it. Suhasini Mulay essays the part of a rustic belle beautifully and her amiable character serves as the perfect foil for Dutt’s mean bureaucrat. One can go on and on talking about the different aspects of Bhuvan Shome. It is a film that can be enjoyed at so many different levels. The movie’s entertainment quotient is surprisingly quite high. If you love movies, Bhuvan Shome wouldn’t disappoint you. It is essential viewing for every student of cinema.

Mrinal Sen, Bengali filmmaker
Mrinal Sen, during the course of his illustrious filmmaking career, has been one of the greatest ambassadors of Indian cinema on the global stage. Sen's cinema is primarily known for its artistic depiction of social reality. Without doubt, he is the greatest filmmaker alive and one of the very few filmmakers ever to have won an award or recognition at all the major cinematic forums in the world. Today, at the age of 93, Mrinal Sen continues to be a great source of inspiration for the students of cinema. His formidable body of work today stands tall amongst the greatest oeuvres in world cinema. Mrinal Sen is a living legend and a modern master of cinema. Recipient of civilian honors like Commandeur de Ordre des Arts et des Lettres (conferred by the French President) and Order of Friendship (awarded by the Russian president), Sen is highly deserving of India's highest civilian honor and it is high time he is conferred the Bharat Ratna. Please support our petition filed at change.org with your valuable vote by visiting the following link:


Readers, please feel free to share your views/opinions in the comment box below. As always your feedback is highly appreciated!

References:



Watch Bhuvan Shome (Rajshri's YouTube Channel )


People who liked this also liked...
Share on Google Plus

6 comments:

  1. "Big Bad Bureaucrat Reformed by Rustic Belle" ...a bit harsh by Ray sir, I would say. But a great review, Murtaza !

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not sure about the review but the movie is certainly great! ☺

      In time, Ray must have changed his opinion. He wouldn't have made Shatranj Ke Khilari had it not been the case.

      Delete
  2. Great to see a wonderful review about a classic film long forgotten... :-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. That's a highly commendable review of a classic.

    Jitendra Mathur

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for sharing for valuable opinion. We would be delighted to have you back.